INTERVIEW: Developing countries risk missing out on net-zero benefits, but fairer future is possible
Inflation fears are subsiding, the “net-zero transition” to a clean economy could spell good news with the right policies in place and we are still dealing with a “COVID hangover”, according to the UN Department for Economic and Social Affairs (DESA).
The lead author of the World Economic Situations and Prospects mid-year update, the flagship report from DESA released on 16 May, outlined the main findings in an interview with UN News.
This interview has been edited and condensed for clarity and length.
Hamid Rashid: Inflation has come down significantly from the 2022 peak, but not to the extent that central banks can say that they have won the war. There's still room for improvement.
At the launch of the report, we mentioned that the US Federal Reserve targets “personal consumption expenditure inflation”, which is not about what you buy, but what you consume and includes rent, including “imputed rent” [what homeowners would pay if they were still renting and how much it would have gone up].
Those numbers are pretty slow moving, and that really makes it difficult for the number to come down very quickly.
Some developing countries still have very high inflation, but, overall, the trend is very positive.
UN News: And the reason we care about this is because there’s very often a lag between the cost of things and how much wages go up?
Hamid Rashid: Exactly. It boils down to standard of living. If prices are going up higher than your wage growth rates, you are basically worse off in real terms.
When inflation is very high, people feel very nervous because they are not able to spend as much, and that becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. They spend less, so the economy slows down even more, and that’s the challenge.
UN News: The Ukraine war has been going on for over two years, and now we have a catastrophic war in Gaza. What effect does conflict have on the global economy?
Hamid Rashid: When the war in Ukraine started, we saw a huge spike in commodity prices. Oil prices shot up. Grain prices shot up. But, they have normalised. Similarly, when the Gaza war began last October, we saw some increases in oil prices and some commodity prices but, again, they stabilised.
The global market is responding to this crisis more efficiently, and alternative sources are emerging, so we haven’t seen a severe effect on prices from the Gaza war. However, we are seeing other effects; freight prices have gone up because the Red Sea route is restricted.
UN News: Because ships can’t travel through that area?
Hamid Rashid: Yes. And when you’re diverted around the Cape of Good Hope, you’re adding another 15 days of travel time, which really adds up a lot of costs.
In general, the biggest headwind right now is geopolitical risk, which is why we have adjusted downward the growth forecast for the majority of the countries in Africa.
UN News: Turning to the impact of COVID-19, your report graph shows that when the coronavirus hit, the global economy almost came to a standstill. But, then there’s quite a sharp rebound after that. Are we getting back to where we would have been if there hadn’t been a pandemic? Or is it still going to be several years before we fully recover?
Hamid Rashid: There’s an illusion there in terms of a huge spike in 2021. It’s what we call the base effect. For example, if you have a massive drop, to minus 10 per cent growth, and the next year you have three per cent growth, it looks amazing.
We absolutely have not gone back to the pre-COVID trajectory of global growth. Indeed, 2023 was a very slow year. Trade is a major driver of economic growth, especially for developing countries that are very dependent on exporting their commodities or manufactured goods, and trade is not back to normal.
UN News: And many countries ended up cutting back on public spending and basic services?
Hamid Rashid: Yes, and we have always been very critical of austerity measures, especially when an economy is on a recovery path, because then you slow down the recovery. That goes for developed and developing countries. We saw this in Greece, Argentina and many other countries.
Governments have to spend to keep the economic momentum going because it brings in private investment. For example, when you build a new road, a company can build a factory. If there’s no road, no one can get to the factory. So, public investment is often a critical catalyst for private investment and economic activities.
UN News: The UN is urging the international community to speed up the transition to an economy that is no longer based on burning the fossil fuels that are driving the climate crisis. One of the consequences is a massive ramping up of the mining of the rare earth minerals that are needed to, for example, power an electric car. In the report, you say this could create a new version of the so-called resource curse, meaning that those who mine these minerals we will need to power this cleaner economy, won’t necessarily benefit from the wealth they create. Can you explain?
Hamid Rashid: Yes, but this is not inevitable, and we suggest that if countries have the right policies in place, they can avoid this consequence. Many are actually moving in the right direction because they’ve learned from past mistakes.
For example, in many African and Latin American countries, the goal was to get as many minerals out of the earth and export it as raw ore and minerals. But, this model is not very sustainable because you don’t get much value.
A tonne of copper ore doesn’t give you much money, but if you can turn it into copper wires and other materials, you can add a lot more value. And that’s what countries are trying to do with innovation and industrial policies.
You have to bring the technology and the right investment. We are more optimistic about the strategic decisions that governments can make.
Find out more about the state of the global economy on UN Weekly, an engaging and entertaining guide to the fascinating, little-known and often misunderstood world of the United Nations.